We are part of The Trust Project What is it?

Apple is so late to the smart speaker party it’s rung the doorbell at 6am and woken up all the sofa surfers in your lounge.

This is nothing new – the iPod and Watch both watched their rivals hit the tequila too hard, before becoming the life and soul of music players and smartwatches.

Still, it’s a bit different this time. Amazon’s Echo army and Google Home’s family are already great voice-controlled speakers that can organise your digital life. The Sonos One, meanwhile, mixes Alexa smarts with great sound quality and multi-room tunes.

But guess what? Apple thinks it can do better. And in some ways, the HomePod, does outshine its fellow party guests.

It’s swept into the room with Apple’s signature hauteur, refusing to speak to nerdy Android phones or go beyond polite conversation with Spotify. A recent iOS update has made it smarter, with support for multi-room audio and stereo pairing, but it's still doing things very much on its terms.

Still, if you’ve got an iPhone, subscribe to Apple Music and prioritise sound quality over A.I assistance, it might just be your new smart soulmate…

Design: soft machine

The HomePod is a 7in tall cylinder that is both charming and unremarkable.

Its mesh fabric gives it a friendly and homely feel, while the white and space grey colours mean it’ll blend in nicely with pretty much any decor (aside from your Angry Birds wallpaper).

The result is a speaker that is eminently more strokable than an Echo or the almost identically-sized Sonos One. But also one that’s not hugely distinguishable from the furry speakers Libratone has been making for years.

On the top you’ll find some basic touch controls that you can use with, gasp, your fingers. How quaint. There are volume up and down buttons, while a series of taps in the middle will control your music: one tap for play or pause, two for next track and three for previous track. Say ‘hey, Siri’, and a ghostly waveform will light up between the buttons to show she’s listening.

This is all very lovely, but one slight shame is that, unlike Google Home and Amazon Echo, there’s no mute button for the microphone. You can mute Siri in the HomePod’s settings, though, if you’re worried she’ll blare out ‘sure, let’s continue playing Michael Buble’ during your dinner party.

And that’s about it, externally. All the clever stuff is hidden underneath the HomePod’s friendly jumper, and this is where things get interesting...

Features: more music nerd than smart home conductor

Apple claims the Siri on the HomePod is a ‘musicologist’. Clearly, Nathan Barley has been consulting at Cupertino. But is there any merit to these claims of musical clairvoyance?

A little, but that’s all so far. What you get are some impressively specific playlists (for example, ‘play me some ambient electronic music for studying’), the ability to quiz Siri about a song or band that’s playing, and the chance to teach Siri your tastes by saying ‘I like this’.

Siri usually answers basic questions well, like ‘what year was this recorded?’ and ‘which album is this from?’. But she couldn’t handle ‘which band is Jamie XX in?’. Come on, Siri, handed that one to you on a plate.

While the number of genres you can choose from is impressive, it’s not yet encylopaedic. Siri didn’t understand my request for ‘garage rock’. My yearning for ‘chamber pop’ was greeted with the pleasantly unexpected sound of a classical orchestra. And grime was interpreted (or perhaps misheard) as ‘crime music’, which seems a little harsh.

In the main, though, Siri on the HomePod proved to be a more knowledgeable musical companion than Alexa or Google Assistant, if not quite the super-nerd I was hoping for. The ‘play something I like’ function, sure enough, played songs I like. But what I really want to ask is ‘play something I’ll eventually like’ and be greeted with a mix of impossibly tailored new songs that don’t feel quite like the ragbag that Spotify Discover Weekly often is.

Siri’s ‘musicologist’ leanings also feel like they’d be most useful for radio. But this is another big weakness – the only station you can stream directly to the HomePod is Beats 1. Like Spotify and other streaming services, you can Airplay most stations, including those from the BBC, to the HomePod from your phone. But there’s a big drop-off in sound quality and Siri can’t answer any questions about the music playing.

This is a big miss for such a music-focused speaker, and it’s not the only chink in the HomePod’s mesh armour…

Smart home skills: Siri needs more time at A.I school

Granted, that list is growing nicely, but it’s still nowhere near as long as the number of accessories that play nicely with Amazon’s Alexa or Google Assistant. Some notable absences include Hive, Nest, Samsung Smartthings and Logitech Harmony remotes.

Still, if your smart home ambitions extend only to some Philips Hue bulbs, a Tado thermostat and some Nanoleaf lights – and to be fair, this is probably most people – then the HomePod is a perfectly decent voice-controlled hub.

Siri has also stepped up his or her overall smart assistant game too. You can do many of the staples popularised by Alexa and Google Assistant, such as set reminders and add things to your shopping list. As long you don’t mind these notes only going to Apple’s equivalent iOS app, rather than your favourite third party ones.

Other common requests that work perfectly well are playing podcasts, getting the weather forecast (most easily accessed by asking ‘will I need an umbrella today?’, if in the UK) and getting an estimate of how heavy the traffic is on a particular route.

But in other ways Siri is like Santa’s Little Helper compared to the Laddie-like collies of Alexa and Google Assistant.

For example, on the HomePod you can’t yet set an alarm to play a song or radio station, only a jingle. Which currently rules it out as a bedside clock radio replacement.

Siri also can’t yet read audiobooks or directly make phone calls. You can pass off phone calls from your iPhone and the microphones will pick up your natural speaking voice from a few feet away, but it’s still a little short of what Alexa can do (particularly with video calls on the Echo Show).

Sending texts did also work fine, but when I tried to send a WhatsApp message (which is supported) Siri said I’d need ‘to continue that on iPhone’.

Apple’s assistant lacks the depth of the Google Assistant’s general knowledge too, and it’s hard to see that changing soon. You can’t, for example, ask for recipes or flight information.

There is an argument that this is because Google is far happier to mine your anonymised data, with Apple underlining that all HomePod requests are both anonymous and encrypted. In the end, you have to decide whether ceding some access data is worth the benefits of something like Google Home.

One final big miss for the HomePod, though, is that it can’t yet recognise different voices. This is particularly helpful for flatmates or families who want to get personalised responses from Google Assistant or Alexa. It’ll surely be coming to the HomePod soon, though there’s nothing official about this yet.

Apple HomePod verdict

The HomePod is, by Apple’s own admission, a music speaker first and a smart assistant second.

That’s fine, but it’s also not really a complete music speaker either – it’s a home Apple Music player for iPhone owners. That makes it very niche and restrictive compared to its rivals from Amazon, Google and Sonos.

What it does better than any of those three, though, is muster incredible sound from one, very pretty speaker.

It's better than a Sonos One (if not twice as good, as the price tag suggests) and it's in another league to the Echo and Home. Siri is also, if far from the best all-round home helper, the most knowledgeable and intelligent virtual music assistant around.

That's not to say there aren't definite holes in the HomePod's armoury. Some of these, like recognising multiple voices and setting alarm radios, feel like simple software fixes. Others, like Siri's comparative lack of general knowledge, are just a fundamentally different approach to smart speakers and data. 

But what the HomePod does well, it does so well that it’s now the benchmark by which we’ll judge musical smart speakers.

Stuff says... 

Apple HomePod review

The best musical smart speaker you can buy, but only if you’re an Apple Music fan and iPhone devotee
£319
Good Stuff 
Incredible sound quality for its size
Homely, minimalist design
Siri has impressive music smarts
Works well as a HomeKit hub
Automatically adjusts sound to suit any room
Bad Stuff 
Voice control only works with Apple Music
No stereo pairing or multi-room support until 'later this year'
Can't yet recognise different voices
Beats 1 is the only radio station you can directly stream
Alexa and Google Assistant are still better all-round voice assistants