Samsung Galaxy S3 vs Sony Xperia Z

05 Feb 2013

Read our Samsung Galaxy S3 and Sony Xperia Z review.

Samsung Galaxy S3 vs Sony Xperia Z – fight!

Android fans are spoilt for choice when it comes to top-end smartphones. A constant stream of new releases keep on raising the bar, while last year's technology quickly becomes affordable. The problem is it can be difficult to know which one to go for, especially when it's the Samsung Galaxy S3 pitted against Sony's Xperia Z upstart. So which Android champion rules the roost?

Samsung Galaxy S3

Samsung Galaxy S3 vs Sony Xperia Z – build and design

Samsung's Galaxy S3 comes in a polycarbonate shell that's relatively strong and able to withstand some punishment – but it meant that the S3 never quite had the premium feel that it deserved. Even so, it was an impressive feat to fit such a large display in such a thin and compact case – and it looks great and feels comfortable to hold.

The Sony Xperia Z, by contrast, comes wrapped in a far more premium-feeling glass frame. It's both more subtle (unless you pick the purple version) and more resilient than the S3, offering both water and dust resistance.

Sony Xperia Z

Samsung Galaxy S3 vs Sony Xperia Z – screen

Up until very recently, the Galaxy S3's display has been almost unrivalled when it comes to quality. 1280x720 resolution means HD-ready detail on a phone, while the brightness and colours are vivid and natural. Suffice to say, that 4.8in Super AMOLED display makes films, games and e-mails are a pleasure to view. Okay, maybe not e-mails. Unless they're really well-written ones.

Unfortunately for the Galaxy S3, the Xperia Z is one of a wave of full 1080p smartphones hitting shops this year. 1920x1080 resolution makes for unrivalled detail, super crisp text and better detail for your films and photos. Those extra pixels more than make up for the jump up in size to 5in. Factor in Sony's excellent Bravia technologies and you have an obvious winner.

Sony Xperia Z

Samsung Galaxy S3 vs Sony Xperia Z – cameras

The Samsung Galaxy S3 snapper packs 8MP, full 1080p video recording at 30 fps and relatively good low-light performance. In short, it can roll with the best phones on the market and the bright, colour accurate results speak for themselves.

Sony has opted to try and raise the bar somewhat higher with a 13.1MP offering. It can automatically jump between 36 scene presets to ensure you get the best possible shot, including HDR for when the exterior light is much brighter than the interior you are trying to capture. Video is of the full 1080 variety, putting it on a par with the Galaxy S3 – but bear in mind that low-light capture delivers less impressive results.

Samsung Galaxy S3 vs Sony Xperia Z – power

At the heart of the Galaxy S3 is the Samsung-built Exynos quad core processor, clocked to 1.4GHz. It also packs 1GB of RAM, resulting in silky smooth transitions – especially if the Jelly Bean update has been liberally applied.

Sony also offers a quad core processor in its Xperia Z, delivering a slightly higher clock speed of 1.5Ghz. You also get 2GB of RAM, resulting in what should be a faster performance. However, without apps and games really making use of that extra juice, it's hard to see a difference for the time being. Still, when it comes to sheer processing grunt, the winner is obvious.

Sony Xperia Z (purple)

Samsung Galaxy S3 vs Sony Xperia Z – verdict

Samsung did a marvellous job with the Galaxy S3 – and it's deservedly sat atop Stuff's Smartphones Top 10 since its launch. It looks good, the features are impressive and pretty much any task you throw at it will be handled without fuss. In short, it's everything a modern-day phone should be – and the passage of time means that it can now be snapped up on a relatively inexpensive contract.

Therefore it was only going to take a true giant to topple the Galaxy S3, and topple the Xperia Z has most certainly done. Internally, the specs raise the bar considerably and its superior build quality means that it's far less likely to suffer the slings and arrows of daily use. No longer will you fear dropping your phone in the toilet, is what we're trying to say. Throw in a great camera and a full 1080p display and you can see why it has knocked the Galaxy S3 off the top spot in our Smartphones Top 10. Your move, Samsung.

You might also like
Lovefilm to show Amazon Studios’ programmes
10 cancelled TV shows Netflix should revive
Sony Xperia Z review

Comments

  1. markster1971

    15 weeks ago

    this is not really a fair comparison. should of waited to Galaxy S4

  2. stardamore

    15 weeks ago

    How can you honestly pit the two phones together?. Xperia Z is the next generation of phones! and it came almost 9 months after the release of S3. Not a fair comparison at all. The "REAL" comparison should be between the GS4 and Xperia Z , in which the GS4 would most certainly win.

  3. Quickzed

    15 weeks ago

    Not a fair comparison?
    The Xperia Z is for sale now.
    Where do you buy a GS4 NOW?

  4. UK1012UK

    15 weeks ago

    Oh dear, there are a lot of upset Samsung fan boys on here. You can't compare the GS4 with this phone because it's not out yet and won't be for a good few months. Get over it already!

  5. UK1012UK

    15 weeks ago

    I want one!

  6. maximitthers

    15 weeks ago

    I have the Sony Acro S and it is an awesome phone (and waterproof as well). I think all the mindless Samsung and Apple sheeple are completely missing the point. What creates a great phone is not one company or one engineer (and certainly not one salesman, which is all that Jobs was), it is a competitive market where new ideas are always being considered, and technology is always being pushed forward from multiple directions. To blindly say how X brand is better than Y brand without any real testing is absurd, and it will result in far inferior products for all of us, once X brand puts Y brand out of business. I know Sony is struggling right now financially, but I am grateful that they are still producing and innovating, adding variety and competition to the world.

  7. pbarracl

    15 weeks ago

    It's a fair comparison of what is available now, you could argue that when the S4 is released, it wouldn't be a fair comparison then neither, albeit, it would more than likely be in favour of the S4, a true comparison could only be performed if everyone brought their phones out at the same time, which they don't!

  8. brawford

    15 weeks ago

    One MAJOR thing they forgot..removable battery. Lots of people won't buy a phone without one and it's a major reason people are so loyal to Samsung. I don't mind dropping £400 on a phone but not if after a year the battery life's dropped to 2/3 as good and I need to carry one of those big USB charger packs everywhere...

Add your comment

You must be logged in to comment