Android Ice Cream Sandwich vs iOS 5

Android 4.0 is in one corner, iOS the other – FIGHT

So, Google has "unleashed Ice Cream Sandwich" – or Android 4.0 – and it's ready to take on iOS5 in the battle for smartphone supremecy. But how do they fare in the ring? Ding ding… Round one.

Android Ice Cream Sandwich vs iOS 5 – user Interface


Ice Cream Sandwich: ICS plays nice with both smartphones and tablets, combining the very best of Gingerbread and Honeycomb.

Its comically-named Roboto typeface keeps it fresh, while Apple-inspired UI tweaks like app folders, instant photo uploads to the cloud and an action bar to replace the physical keys keep everything flowing smoothly. Then there's the webOS-inspired flick-to-dismiss gesture while multitasking. Gingerbread icons have also been swapped for resizable Honeycomb-style widgets and notifications are accessible from the lock screen.

Multitasking is the real improvement, though, utilising the Recent Apps button in Honeycomb to pull up a list of open apps used in thumbnail form.

iOS 5: Unlike ICS, iOS 5 hasn't been overhauled, and on face value it appears almost identical to previous versions. Start prodding and sliding your way around, though, and you'll find new icons and apps for Videos, Music, Newsstand, iMessage and Reminders, a customisable Android-style Notifications Centre feature and integrated Twitter functionality. Notifications and camera can now be accessed from the lock screen, too, but multitasking remains exactly the same as before.


Android Ice Cream Sandwich vs iOS 5 – hardware

Ice Cream Sandwich: The Galaxy Nexus is going to be the only phone this side of 2012 to sport the new OS. So if you're not particularly fond of Google's new toy, next year is when everything else gets a look in, including the newly announced Motorola RAZR.

The good news? Google has confirmed it's working on an ICS update for the Samsung Nexus S and other Gingerbread-flavoured devices. Unlike Apple, Ice Cream Sandwich fans have the luxury of choice, with a myriad of handsets available next year sporting the new OS.

iOS: As ever, Apple's new OS spans the majority of its ecosystem – and of course comes as standard on the new iPhone 4S. So whether you've got an iPhone 3GS or 4, iPod or iPad, you can upgrade to the latest version via iTunes. The only caveat? No Apple products = no iOS 5.


Android Ice Cream Sandwich vs iOS 5 – tools


Ice Cream Sandwich: Android offers more data control by charting and even curbing usage. Bumped up Gmail previews and offline mail search are a bonus, as is 16-tab browsing with live previews and Google Chrome bookmark sync.

A whole host of improvements have been baked into the photo-taking department, too. We’re talking about reduced shutter lag, panorama mode, time-lapse functionality and a basic image editor. Unlocking your phone with your face and its NFC-equipped Beam feature for sharing stuff are pretty nifty additions, too.

There may be no Siri onboard, but Android's improved voice command system is on hand awaiting instructions. It's certainly not as clever as Apple's "virtual assistant," but Siri might encourage Google to raise its game for the next installment.

iOS 5: Siri is undoubtedly the star of the show and has taken voice recognition to the next level. iOS 5 also debuts iCloud – so it's playing catch up with Android, much like its over-the-air system updates – automatically pushing all multimedia, documents, calendars and mail to your iOS devices.

Apple also chucks in grid lines, face detection and image stabilisation to its camera capabilities, alongside viewfinder pinch to zoom functionality and (finally) the ability to use the volume + key as a shutter button.

Apple's also added a Reading List feature to Safari, allowing users to view pages offline. Much like Android 4.0, iCloud keeps this reading list synced across Apple devices, while the free iMessage service, Wi-Fi syncing and PC-free setup are the icing atop this Apple shaped cake.


Android Ice Cream Sandwich vs iOS 5 – in use

Ice Cream Sandwich: Android's core user experience has never been as polished as iOS. But the times are 'a changing and improved multi-tasking means you can flit between apps and features at a satisfyingly fast pace. Like Honeycomb, widgets now have their own tab in the apps screen, too. Throw in Flash and you're looking at an all-round smartphone experience. 

iOS 5: Leave a child alone with your iPhone and they'll master it in minutes. iOS 5 is that intuitive. Now that it's borrowed a few tricks from Android, its intuitiveness has gone up a notch. Chuck iCloud, Wi-Fi Sync and features like Newsstand into the equation and you’re looking at an extremely clever UI and a continued hassle-free user experience.

Android Ice Cream Sandwich vs iOS 5 – staying social

Ice Cream Sandwich: Rebranding all your contacts as 'People' is very Windows Phone 7, but it does mean your favourite and most contacted pals are easily accessible from one place. Contact Cards take care of ICS's social side by pulling in photos and contact details from all your social networks and letting you have a nose through aggregated posts and updates.

iOS 5: Apple has finally caught up with the competition by throwing in Twitter integration – so sharing info from multiple platforms with strangers is even easier. Unlike Ice Cream Sandwich, social network contacts aren't integrated into the phone's contacts, so social networking information is only accessible via the dedicated apps. Not great if you're a social butterfly, but an absolute godsend if you like to keep social shenanigans, aggregated feeds and linked contacts as far away from your user experience as possible.


Android Ice Cream Sandwich vs iOS 5 – verdict

Google has tried time and time again to beat Apple at its own game, and iOS has remained victorious. But times are a-changing. Both operating systems have a vast number of identical features that make them equally appealing, but it feels like Android just has the edge when it comes to notifications, multitasking and web browsing.

A combination of iOS-inspired-instalments, complimented by its own non-Apple tweaks means Google has rolled out its most aggressive and advanced Android update yet, delivering something completely fresh to the forefront of Android smartphones.

Apple may rule the roost in the app department, but its user experience is starting to feel slightly hackneyed, even with a fresh injection of UI tweaks. With greater customisation options, more control and a complete overhaul Ice Cream Sandwich is, on paper, putting its feet more firmly forward than its iOS counterpart. If Android apps could up their game, too, we feel that even hardened Apple aficionados might find their loyalty wavering.

You may also like

Motorola RAZR 2011 hands on

Motorola ACTV hands on

Galaxy Nexus vs Motorola RAZR

Need to know – Galaxy Nexus

Samsung Galaxy Nexus knows what you look like