Apple iPod 5G Review

£240Nov 2006

Stuff says 5 Hot Buy

Hardly a major overhaul, but the best mp3 jukebox just keeps getting better

Images

Video review

Stuff magazine Thu, Nov 16 2006, 7:00AM

These days, iPods are so common it’s easy to underestimate the brilliance of the high-capacity MP3 king. This new 80GB version delivers on the promise of carrying your entire music collection with you, no matter how swollen. And, despite its huge capacity, the 80GB iPod is still smaller (and much sexier) than its most obvious rivals: Creative’s Zen Vision M and Microsoft’s Zune.

So what are the improvements over last year’s 60GB iPod? Aside from the obvious capacity boost, the new version has a better battery life (a decent 14 hours music playback or over three hours of video) and a better display.

Improved sound and vision
The screen stays the same at 2.5in, but it's much brighter, and
video looks significantly smoother and more natural – which is just as well, as Apple is now selling full-length movies via the iTunes store, but only in the U.S. at the moment – expect the service to be launched here soon, don’t worry, we’ll keep you posted.

While iTunes movies are available at a decent 640x480 resolution, the iPod’s screen is still only 320x240 pixels, which suggests that this iPod is a stop-gap measure before a large-screen Video iPod appears in 2007.

Don’t let that put you off taking the plunge, though. If you’re after a large-capacity music player, the iPod really does deliver – it’s easy to use, sounds good (especially if you upgrade the supplied earphones) and benefits greatly from the excellent iTunes software.

And if you're keen on its video capabilities, remember you can also output 640x480-pixel video to TV via S-Video – if you’re willing to spend £25 on an optional dock. The resulting video is watchable – it’s better than VHS quality, but that’s hardly a badge of pride in these days of high definition.

As well as movies, you can also now buy games for the iPod through the iTunes Store. Classic puzzlers like Tetris and Bejewelled are given a glorious graphical makeover, but all that useless beauty can’t hide the fact that you have to control them with a scrollwheel. And at £4 each the games are over 30 percent more expensive in the UK than in the US. We advise a Nintendo DS instead, if you can afford it. If not, you might still get more value from mobile phone games.

But overpriced software is the least of Apple’s problems. While the company quickly quarantined a recent batch of virus-infected iPods, there are still many reports of failing hard drives – including three 5G casualties within our offices. Apple usually picks up and replaces faulty iPods within a couple of days of reporting a problem, but only if the unit is still under warranty – after a year, you’re on your own.

Scratching is less of an issue, but you’d be well advised to keep your ’Pod in a case. If you do pick up scratches, you can find some home-made solutions on the web which involve using mild abrasives such as Brasso – this can work, but you do it at your own risk.

Microsoft’s iPod rival, Zune, might not have the iPod licked first time round, but they have the money and time to mount a serious challenge.

Comments

  1. Sharkman

    5 years ago

    I agree with the your review on the 80GB Classic. I have recently replaced my 2nd gen 4GB nano with the 80GB Classic, with a top quality Incase leather sleeve which adds superb protection for the Ipod. But as so many people have said in the past the supplied headphones are ok but an upgrade to a decent pair of phones makes all the difference in sound quality. I have chosen a pair of Sennheiser PX100's which for the money are Superb.

  2. markyp1234

    6 years ago

    I agree, on the whole. My 80GB replaced a dead 4G iPod (top marks to Apple - they replaced it within question within 10 days), and has worked like a charm. In fact, the only problem came with the upgrade to iTunes 7 - the first sync resulted in a frozen iTunes and a frozen iPod! Luckily, a simple reboot for both cleared the issue, and it hasn't missed a beat ever since. The exterior is fragile: I bought a decent case for mine on the first day of ownership, and would hate to think of the state it would be in without it. Lastly, I can't understand why Apple continues to sell such a great player with such so-so headphones: upgrade to a decent pair of Sennheisers, and marvel at the difference.

Add your comment

You must be logged in to comment