Should you upgrade from Xbox One to One S?

Torn over whether to swap your Xbox One for the shiny new One S? Let us help

So the new Microsoft Xbox One S is here, and the good news is… it’s great.

Actually, scrub that – it’s fantastic. Microsoft’s new games machine rights the wrongs of the original Xbox One in some style, while bringing 4K output to the party in a way that moves the console goalposts. As our Microsoft Xbox One S review makes clear, it’s currently the best console you can buy and Sony’s PlayStation Neo will have to go some to beat it when it arrives later this year.

All of which makes deciding whether to upgrade a simple matter, then. Well no. Because while it’s undoubtedly better than the Xbox One, it’s also going to cost you another £349. So is that a price worth paying? Here’s what we think. 

Xbox One S - should you upgrade? Design

Let’s start with an easy one: looks-wise the Xbox One S is Scarlett Johansson to the Xbox One’s Piers Morgan. The biggest change is that it no longer has an ugly, unnecessary lump hooked up to it. No, we’re not talking about Piers Morgan, but rather the power brick that most consoles did away with in 2006.

Even without taking that into account it’s a prettier device: it’s 40% smaller and has more subtle stylings than the first Xbox One. Plus, it’ll happily sit next to your TV vertically, with the help of a free stand.

So, if you’re one of those shallow, image-obsessed types who values form over function, upgrading from the Xbox One to the Xbox One S is a no-brainer. And yes, that describes me to a tee.

Should you upgrade to the Xbox One S based on Design: YEAH 

Xbox One S - should you upgrade? Controller

Nobody’s going to upgrade their console based on just a new controller - well, unless somebody releases one with the awesome Sega Mega Drive controller, and then I’m in. But still, it could help sway your purchasing decision if it’s particularly good. So, is it particularly good? Well sort of.

It’s basically the same as the Xbox One controller but with a greater wireless range, added Bluetooth connection for easily hooking up to PCs, and some dimples. Said dimples cover the controller’s back and supposedly give you greater grip - in our test we didn’t notice much benefit to them.

In short, it’s a teeny bit better than the last one. No, you’re not going to upgrade for it, especially since you can buy a standalone model for an existing Xbox One for a £50 outlay. Oh, and it still lacks wireless charging. Move along please.

Should you upgrade to the Xbox One S based on the new controller: NAH 

Xbox One S - should you upgrade? 4K Blu-rays

No tricky decisions to make here - if you have a 4K TV and want to watch Ultra HD Blu-rays on it, the Xbox One S is your new best friend. As it stands there are only two dedicated Ultra HD players, the Panasonic DMP-UB900 and the Samsung UBD-K8500. Both will outperform the Xbox One S purely in terms of picture quality, but the Panasonic costs £600, so unless you’re a proper AV nerd it’s most likely too expensive.

The Samsung costs £349, ie the same as the Xbox One S, but you don’t get all the gaming skills the console offers. Or rather, you don’t get any gaming skills. It’s a Blu-ray player, remember.

Should you upgrade to the Xbox One S based on 4K Blu-rays: YEAH 

Xbox One S - should you upgrade? 4K gaming

4K gaming on the Xbox One S is not really 4K gaming, because the console won’t natively play games in 4K resolution - instead, it’ll upscale full HD games for your 4K TV. That’s actually no different from what your 4K TV will do if you plug an original Xbox One into it, but the One S has more processing power and will do the job more effectively than any telly would if given the same task.

And let’s face it, if you’ve already splurged the cash to buy a high-res telly, it makes sense to pair it with a high-res games machine that will take best advantage of all those pixels on offer.

Because the One S can output full 4K, there is the chance that future games will run at that resolution natively. Then again, that’ll require huge amounts of processing power, so don’t expect to be playing Titanfall 4K any time soon. Tetris 4K is a possibility though.

Should you upgrade to the Xbox One S based on 4K gaming: YEAH 

Xbox One S - should you upgrade? HDR

HDR is the other trump card up the One S’ sleeve. Most new 4K-capable TVs will also play nice with HDR, and the chances are any Ultra HD disc you watch will be both. On the gaming front your options are currently more limited, in that the only HDR-ready games currently announced are the forthcoming Gears Of War 4 and Forza Horizon 3.

Either way, it’s a great option to have, as HDR is awesome, making the dark bits in scenes darker and the light bits lighter and generally making it all look great. If you have an HDR-capable TV, you’ll want to take advantage of it, basically.

Should you upgrade to the Xbox One S based on HDR: YEAH 

Xbox One S - should you upgrade? Cost

The new Xbox One S costs £349, whereas the old Xbox One can be found for as little as £245 right now - a sizeable difference that could equate to a couple of new top-tier games or a whole library of second-hand and indie titles.

Assuming you already own an Xbox One of course, you’d get a bit of cash back for selling your existing model - on eBay they generally go for between £100 and £150 depending on condition and hard drive size etc. CEX will buy a 500GB model for £95 or a 1TB model with Elite Controller for £165, meanwhile, all of which would help soften the pain on your wallet.

So what are you getting for that extra £200-£250 outlay? Not very much if you don’t have a 4K TV, plenty if you do.

Should you upgrade to the Xbox One S based on the cost: POSSIBLY 

Xbox One S - should you upgrade? Future-proofing

Nobody wants to buy a console only to find out it’s obsolete weeks later. Just ask anyone who bought a Wii U. Mee-ow!

And that, in a nutshell, is the Xbox One S’ biggest problem. PlayStation’s new ‘Neo’ console will almost certainly arrive before Christmas and is expected to be every bit as 4K-capable as the One S. In fact it may be more so, with rumours that’ll it upscale games from 2K to 4K rather than from 1080p.

More problematic still is that Microsoft’s own Scorpio will arrive in 2017 and should be at least as powerful as the Neo. So not only will the One S lose its status as the most powerful console in a few months, it’ll even lose its status as the most powerful Microsoft console before 2018.

Should you upgrade to the Xbox One S based on future-proofing: NAH 

Xbox One S - should you upgrade from the Xbox One? Verdict

And there you have it. While the Microsoft Xbox One is a really rather excellent console, it’s unlikely to stay the best for that long, so unless you own a 4K TV we’d recommend you stick with what you have.

If you do own a 4K TV, it gets a bit more complicated.

If you own a 4K telly but don’t yet own a 4K Blu-ray player, and were planning to get one, you should look no further - the Xbox One S is the cheapest way to get those high-def discs playing on your high-res telly, and will do it pretty well to boot. And if your TV also does HDR, there’s all the more reason to buy it.

However, if you already own a 4K Blu-ray player or are happy sticking with what’s on offer on Netflix, Amazon and YouTube - or if you don’t own a 4K at all yet - you can give this upgrade a miss.

Buy the Xbox One S here from Microsoft

Liked that? Read this...